
Story Highlight
– Subdial raised $20 million for expansion plans.
– Chronext’s rapid growth led to significant operational challenges.
– Bremont struggles with profitability despite substantial investments.
– Hodinkee retreated from retail after revenue decline.
– Subdial advised to focus on UK growth before USA.
Full Story
Subdial, a UK-based retailer of pre-owned watches, has successfully secured $20 million in funding from seasoned investors, marking a significant milestone in its growth journey. However, the excitement around this development prompts a cautious reflection on past experiences within the retail and investment landscape.
Chronext, a cautionary tale from the watch industry, serves as a notable example. Founded in Germany in 2013, the company sought to transform the fragmented luxury watch market into a scalable online business. Initially relying on personal savings and bank loans, Chronext soon turned to venture capital to fuel its ambitious expansion plans. By 2019, it was campaigning for €25 million from investors, forecasting sales of €500 million and EBITDA of €32 million by 2023, with a projected first profit anticipated in 2021.
In February 2020, Chronext secured a further $65 million to enhance its growth strategy. Despite reporting revenue of approximately €101 million that year, the company faced challenges as the secondary watch market began to fluctuate. The planned flotation in Switzerland was halted in October 2021 due to adverse market conditions, and by 2022, falling watch prices necessitated significant cutbacks, including the layoff of 40 employees.
Philipp Man, the company’s founder, was replaced as CEO in 2023, and restructuring proceedings for the German business commenced in August 2024. Eventually, the Platform Group acquired Chronext’s assets in December, with incoming CEO Frederike Knop stressing the need for a realistic approach moving forward.
While every business has its unique narrative, Bremont’s story shares some similarities. Launched in 2002 by brothers Nick and Giles English, Bremont aimed to reinvigorate British watchmaking, necessitating considerable investment in production capabilities. The brand opened its 35,000 sq ft manufacturing facility, The Wing, in 2021, but had recorded operating losses consecutively from 2015 to 2020 as expansion outpaced profitability.
In January 2023, Bremont announced a significant investment of £48.4 million from financier Bill Ackman and current investor Hellcat to bolster international operations. Yet, financial results revealed a stark gap between ambition and reality, with a turnover of £20.4 million and an operating loss of £13.9 million reported for the year ending June 2023. The constraints imposed by resource allocation towards manufacturing limited its product range, necessitating a re-evaluation of strategy under new CEO Davide Cerrato.
Despite a slight increase in sales in the next financial year, Bremont’s losses persisted, highlighting the difficulties of balancing investment with operational capacity. By April 2025, Ackman had raised his stake in the company to 63%, leading to board changes and the departure of its founders.
For Subdial, the focus of the newly acquired capital will primarily be on increasing its inventory and expanding its presence in the competitive US market. The company has efficiently built a robust following on social media platforms, attracting nearly 400,000 followers, which aids in its marketing efforts.
However, the experience of watch media and retail outlet Hodinkee illustrates the risks involved. Once at the forefront of the watch media landscape, Hodinkee expanded into retail, raising $40 million in late 2020 to enhance its ecommerce capabilities. This ambitious move eventually exposed the company to considerable inventory costs and, when the market shifted in 2022, it experienced a significant revenue drop, necessitating layoffs and a strategic retreat from retail operations.
Subdial aims to penetrate the US market, acknowledging the potential challenges ahead. Complexities associated with cross-border trading can severely impact margins, and the success achieved in the UK does not guarantee similar results in the more competitive American landscape. Watchfinder & Co., another existing player, has struggled to replicate its UK success in the US, suffering substantial losses in the process.
Moreover, the US watch market is dominated by established entities such as Bucherer, WatchBox, and European Watch Company, all of which are firmly entrenched in the industry and present formidable competition. Meanwhile, Subdial’s recent growth trajectory in the UK, which led to a reported turnover increase of 64% year-on-year, positions it as a potential leader in the domestic pre-owned luxury watch market. If it can maintain its growth without overextending, it may continue to thrive.
In conclusion, Subdial’s funding offers a wealth of opportunity, but prudent decisions regarding its investment focus will be crucial. Transitioning directly into the US market could pose significant risks, thus building upon the existing UK infrastructure while carefully exploring international avenues may provide a more stable path to sustainable growth.